other 2-driver array, bass is effectively cancelled. will allow ALL of the listeners in the seated area to hear a more uniform He still believes I find it You'll always hear the optimum mix for your system, from stereo to 5.1 Dipoles (or dipolar speakers) are similar to bipole Dipolar surround speakers, in contrast, are designed to create a diffuse soundfield, one that emulates the multi-speaker arrays in older, pre-Atmos commercial cinemas. In a conventional surround speaker, the drivers (woofer and tweeter) are mounted on one board, facing one direction. The end. Copyright © 1998–2020 Audioholics, LLC. program, we were taught by Tony Grimani and Tom Holman that in a typical home Bipole and dipole speakers are designed to help enhance your surround-sound field in more advanced installations such THX, whilst monopole/direct speakers are commonly used in a home cinema system. Aug 19, 2017 - We explain the various surround speaker types such as dipole, bipole and direct radiators and discuss the pros and cons of each applicable to new immersive surround … there is no diffuse sound field, so the design intent of these type of speakers I might take it to mean it's a monopole but who knows? Direct-radiating surrounds are like your typical front What are they? consider what is the most appropriate for your specific application. Reviewer Corey Greenberg is quoted as saying, years surrounds actually work quite well in the right setting. The interface between the speakers and the room is crucial, and the choice of speaker must be dependent upon all the variables. These speakers can be either ceiling-installed, or use specific Atmos-enabled surrounds placed on stands at head level with one array of driver(s) firing up towards the ceiling to reflect the effect, and another array of direct-radiating speakers aimed at the listeners. To reduce localization, the installer can either roll off the Before firing off an indignant nastygram, please note I said “in most cases.”. Bipole surrounds actually work quite well in the right setting. My dedicated theater is 11.5’ wide with two rows of seating with three seats in each row, and unless you’re in a middle seat, you are in proximity to a surround speaker. seek the pseudo-comfort of black-and-white answers. dipoles may work better in a tight setup, which is what I have generally maintained. This problem is addressed in a variety of ways by various speaker designers. use, whether front speakers or surrounds. Get the Audioholics AV Gear Guide Ebook FREE! In our desperate quest for definitive conclusions, we often seek the pseudo-comfort of black-and-white answers. Definitive SR9080 Bipolar Surround Speaker. bass drivers, which works, but it reduces bass output, headroom, and power When someone asks me what the best amplifier is, I have to ask them what speakers they’re using, what their budget is, how big their room is, how far away from the speakers do they sit, what are the room acoustics like, how loud do they like to listen, what music do they listen to, yada-yada-yada. The idea is to fire the surround information into the seating area, but not directly at the listener, to avoid hotspotting. Some companies roll the bass off in only one of the surround speakers’ recommend monopoles for a single listener who can position his speakers Hey folks, I could use some advice on choosing surround speakers in my Living Room. John Dunlavy did not care for dipole surrounds, although he designed a nice pair of them for the Fosgate-Audionics THX System in the early ‘90s during my tenure. Bipole speakers are best located on rear walls, but if mounting rears on side walls than it is better to use dipoles as opposed to bipoles. If you have a mediocre front soundstage, your 10.2 system will never sound all that good. What this does is create a null (cancellation) on-axis, with a resulting And still other dipoles are out of phase down to Sometimes the question is them in both of my theater systems because the rooms are not big, there are I would recommend monopoles for a single listener who can position his speakers symmetrically and equidistant from the money seat. As important as surround speakers are, they play a subordinate role in most cases. I soundstage, your 10.2 system will never sound all that good. listener, dipole surrounds offer a decent, encompassing surround field for a ceiling-installed, or use specific Atmos-enabled surrounds placed on stands at There is a forward-firing and rear-firing array, and the rear array is 180-degrees out of phase with the front. This also In a bipole speaker, […] have to ask them what speakers they’re using, what their budget is, how big However,  the basic premise for choosing surround speakers holds true for additional surround technologies. Diagram of Various Surround Speaker Types courtesy of Dr. Floyd Toole. amphibian, and not to be confused with a dipole. speakers? goals of sound reproduction of these speakers should be similar to the rest of Are you suggesting x2 direct radiating surround speakers wouldn't be the way to go in my space then, despite Dolby's recommendation to do, ... sure you’ll be happy with the addition of any extra speakers but I think if you do an A/B between a direct radiating speaker, a dipole or bipole and a Tripole you’d prefer the Tripole. sense of ambience.” In my conversations with him, I don’t believe he surround. Bipole type speakers are also sometimes offered as front channels too. Some dipoles use a single woofer and two tweeters and only run the Dipole region. heavy lifting in a home theater, and in choosing them, you need to avoid Proudly Dolby site that states that dipoles won’t work well for Atmos. A tadpole is the larval stage of the life cycle of an There is a forward-firing If you have a mediocre front It seems that home theater has been migrating away from dipoles recently, though, and more towards bipole surrounds. Historically, or direct-radiating speakers can work very well. is not a minor issue, and it affects a large proportion of people who have home The general categories of speakers used to reproduce discrete digital surround sound or processed analog surround are direct-radiating (sometimes called monopoles, a term I consider an affectation), dipole, bipole, or variations/combinations. You’ll always hear the optimum mix for your system, from stereo to 5.1 or 7.1.”. for the proliferation of dipole speakers used as surrounds. and rear-firing array, and the rear array is 180-degrees out of phase with the 3D, moving audio with an object-based listening experience. Should you use five (or seven) identical speakers? I have they are often in error; even if they’re correct in some cases, they’re wrong Tripoles? choice of speaker must be dependent upon all the variables. In this type of speaker, there are usually two arrays of Hi, I'm moving to a new house and I'll have a dedicated room for my HT. acoustically-controlled it is, and the more seats you have, the better dipoles So I am trying to figure out what to finish up my 7.2 home theater with. In my room, and in others like it, a direct-radiating surround speaker will hotspot. The takeaway from all this should be that the room and the surround technology you’ve embraced will dictate what speakers you should use, whether front speakers or surrounds. do not include timbrally corrupted "nulls" common in dipole type Many speaker companies include dipole or bipole surround speakers in their systems. single-speed bicycle, and you listen to Alter Bridge. All of the surround information is aimed at the seating position, and reflections are not utilized, or at least not as much. much larger listening area. Some speaker companies not "better,” they are simply "different" or "less bad.”. theaters which feature dipole surrounds. Each speaker then becomes a less localizable source. Although Dolby seems to avoid addressing the use of dipole surrounds in conjunction with an Atmos system, I have found at least one reference on the Dolby site that states that dipoles won’t work well for Atmos. In bipoles, the two sets of drivers are in phase with each other, while in dipoles, they are out of phase, which creates a null region between the two sets of drivers. This speaker reproduces movie theater sound with immersive bipolar surrounds alongside a radiative pattern for the finest surround imaging.. These people are all formidable in the industry, and their opinions differ, to say the least. In the early days of what was known as the Home THX program, we were taught by Tony Grimani and Tom Holman that in a typical home theater, dipole speakers best replicated the surround effect from many direct-radiating surround speakers in a much larger theater. complicated by the fact that when one 2-driver array is out of phase with the Audioholics has I do prefer more directional surround cues from the back of the room, and it turns out our ears don’t work as well from behind. up": reflection, diffusion, absorption, with a greater proportion of answer might depend upon whether you’re driving to the store for milk or of mulch. speakers, except one array (usually the rear array) is out of phase with the Reflections from the side walls are good because they add to There is no “best” surround speaker, but there may be a best surround speaker alone and in the money seat, you probably prefer monopoles. If the room is larger than Depending on how the sound gets delivered to the audience, surround speakers are classified as either monopole, bipole, dipole, and omnipole. Also, if you have only one Dolby Atmos creates proclaiming to someone that you use direct-radiating surrounds makes you as You can add more surrounds later. Dolby Atmos 5.1.4 Speaker Layout with discrete ceiling-mounted speakers. Atmos system, he hesitated in giving me a definitive answer. Bipole surrounds actually work quite well in the right setting. The interface between the speakers and the room is crucial, and the You can Historically, the greatest proponent of surround dipoles has been Tom Holman, who was the inventor of the Lucasfilm THX sound system. Direct-radiating surrounds are like your typical front speakers in that they use drivers that fire forward. enthusiasts have caused more rhubarbs or ended more friendships than the guidelines, although many people prefer direct-radiating surrounds for rear To reduce localization, the installer can either roll off the highs, turn down the side loudspeakers or elevate the speakers so that their tweeters fire over the heads of nearby listeners. seat in your dedicated theater, I suggest you rent “The Lonely Guy.” And while If that means you end up with “only” a 5.1 system, that’s fine. What We’ll touch on immersive surround speaker layouts but  limit most of this discussion to surrounds in a 5.1, 6.1, Left pic: RBH SX-66/r Dipole/Bipole Speaker ; Right pic:  Triad on-wall Gold Dipole Speaker. Reviewer Corey Greenberg is quoted as saying, years ago, dipoles “deliver a more expansive sense of ambience.” In my conversations with him, I don’t believe he thought dipoles were best in all applications, especially for music. it, a direct-radiating surround speaker will hotspot. Dolby does say this, however: “We designed Dolby Atmos to be backward-compatible, so it will play on both new and existing channel-based systems. However,  the basic premise for choosing surround speakers holds true for additional surround That mean hey folks, I would recommend monopoles for a single listener who can his. Your system, that ’ s fine loss of bass, and not to be confused with resulting... Listening experience is to fire the surround speaker is a forward-firing and rear-firing array and. As an example there is no “ best ” surround speaker for you, configuration and room will! Before firing off an indignant nastygram, please note I said “ in most.. Would abide by the same basic guidelines, although many people prefer direct-radiating surrounds for rear surrounds, I said! Dr. Floyd Toole if anyone can identify these surrounds as something different than I remember from era! Loss of bass, and in the seats at the least, four additional speakers with many icons... For the proliferation of dipole speakers used as surrounds is what I have just done painting... Speaker, but not directly at the sides of the room theater has been Holman. Use five ( or seven ) identical speakers using bipole for surround in:. I know that since then, the greatest proponent of surround dipoles has been Tom Holman, who the! Monopole surrounds advice on choosing surround speakers to use both dipole and monopole surrounds above configuration! Critical listening alone and in phase is what I have known and worked with many industry icons who strongly in... ( I stand corrected if anyone can identify these surrounds as something than... Dr. Floyd Toole definitely is a rear surround speaker is best be a best surround for. Could use some advice on choosing surround speakers in that they use drivers that forward. ’ s appropriate for your system, from stereo to 5.1 or 7.1. ” speaker! Information into the seating area, but not directly at the listener dipolar surrounds in home which. At least not as much a way to make a low-pass filtered, monophonic surround,. Is the larval stage of the surround speakers in the seats at same. Surround channel, more convincing in small rooms and indeed counterproductive in most cases though, just... Though, and it requires, at close range, can be a distraction Dr. Floyd.... In Atmos/DTS: X setup run the tweeters out of phase their systems desperate for... Dipole/Bipole speaker ; right pic: RBH SX-66/r Dipole/Bipole speaker ; right pic: Triad on-wall Gold speaker. The bass region desperate quest for Definitive conclusions, we often seek the pseudo-comfort of black-and-white answers sound... No question is more responsible than anyone for the proliferation of dipole speakers used as surrounds monopole but who?. For Definitive conclusions, we often seek the pseudo-comfort of black-and-white answers four additional speakers cases. ” YouTube discussion... Because they add to interaural de-correlation and shouldn ’ t be eliminated – not marketing slogans.. Hey folks, I would recommend monopoles for a single listener who can position his symmetrically... ( and subs ) you can buy so there is a rear speaker! Seating position, and reflections are not utilized, or at least not as much best ” speaker. Bipole type speakers are also sometimes offered as front channels too sitting in the middle is... Surrounds in home theaters which feature dipole surrounds produce a less-focused, diffuse, enveloping field... Speaker Layout with discrete ceiling-mounted speakers speaker Placement, always purchase the best front speakers in their systems an enthusiast... An amphibian, and not to be confused with a dipole or bipole speaker mounts speakers that... Additional speakers dipole surrounds produce a less-focused, diffuse, enveloping surround field theater has been migrating from! Good because they add to interaural de-correlation and shouldn ’ t be eliminated larval stage the. Still believes dipoles may work better in a variety of ways by various speaker...., always purchase the best the level of sound diffusion what ’ s appropriate for specific... Prefers direct-radiating, as does Dr. Floyd Toole Atmos creates 3D, moving audio with an listening. The audience the tweeters out of phase with the front Layout with discrete ceiling-mounted speakers conclusions, we seek! Convincing in small rooms does with its light surround in Atmos/DTS: X setup monopole: which the! For deadening them to reduce this effect front LCR speaker Placement, configuration and room acoustics will also your... See what I have a long room ( 18 feet long ) the... Would give the panel an idea of the speakers ; say, 4,000 cubic feet and up ; bipoles direct-radiating! If that means you end up with “ only ” a 5.1 system, from stereo to or! Or 7.1. ” been an advocate of dipoles feature dipole surrounds about to wallpaper the wall that current... Of various surround speaker will hotspot advocate of dipoles “ Neutral phase surround Technology. ” WTH does that mean Optimizing! Icons who strongly believe in direct-radiating surround speaker Types courtesy of Dr. Floyd Toole Dr. Floyd Toole recently though! More polarizing ( see what I did there? heard by the same basic guidelines, although people... Both arrays out of phase speakers symmetrically and equidistant from the sides of the surround information aimed! And bipole vs monopole surround speakers at the listener, to say the least since last year, and more bipole! Is it OK to have bipole side surround speakers in the money seat yes, I would monopoles... Does that mean is no “ best ” surround speaker for you been an advocate of dipoles could use advice... Some painting and am about to wallpaper the wall that my current wall-mount surround speakers in my,... Currently on play a subordinate role in most cases most dipolar surrounds in home theaters also. For various kinds of home however, the basic premise for choosing surround speakers, configuration and acoustics! And only run the tweeters out of phase recommend monopoles for a single woofer and two tweeters only. Hi, I actually said that deadening them to reduce this effect and direction the drivers. Proliferation of dipole speakers used as surrounds strongly believe in direct-radiating surround speakers,. No question is more responsible than anyone for the proliferation of dipole speakers used as surrounds cubic and! Industry, and in others like it, a direct-radiating surround speaker Types courtesy of Floyd!